-----------------------------------------------------------------------
S-38.149 Postgraduate Course in Teletraffic Theory, Fall 2004
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Review Form
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Paper: ...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Recommendation (1-6): ...
(1:top 100%, 2:top 60%, 3:top 40%, 4:top 20%, 5:top 10%, 6:top 1%)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Brief summary: 

...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Importance: 
What are the major issues addressed in the paper? Do you consider 
these issues important?

...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Contribution: 
Do the presented results constitute a significant advance (e.g., 
technical depth, novelty, creative solution, etc.)? (1-3 sentences)

...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Strengths: 
What are the most important reasons to accept this paper? 
(1-3 sentences) (e.g., advances the state of the art in..., 
explores the new research area of..., provides useful results for...)

...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Weaknesses: 
What are the most important reasons NOT to accept this paper? 
(1-3 sentences) (e.g., the paper has serious technical mistakes, 
isn't novel, does not demonstrate its point by 
proofs/simulations/experiments, makes very unreasonable assumptions, 
etc.)

...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Detailed comments to the authors: 

...

-- END ----------------------------------------------------------------